Lille 0 vs Manchester United 1 - A review

Two key things happened on Tuesday night. Firstly, United showed an ability to adapt and overcome an awkward game that looked destined to end 0-0. Secondly, Lille made an incredibly poor error of judgement that could ultimately see them penalised by UEFA. There was nothing wrong with them protesting to the referee immediately after the goal was awarded, BUT to kick the ball out of touch and then for their coaching staff to blatantly encourage them off the field of play was as deliberate as it was disrespectful. To make matters worse their management have sought to blame this act on “an emotional moment”. According to their manager (Puel) "In France the tradition is to make a protest at the first pause in the game and then after the match”. I am not sure that the UEFA will share the sentiment that French tradition is more important than the rules.

So what will happen to Lille? I expect a heavy fine and perhaps a touchline ban to be the decision. Calls for Lille to be removed from the competition are a touch ITV – i.e. overly dramatic.

Returning to the game, the main pleasing aspect was United’s ability to give a patient and professional performance. It was this that led to United returning home with an important advantage and the bonus of having kept a clean sheet – something no other English club was able to do. In previous campaigns United would have conceded. With Van der Saar, Ferdinand and Vidic at the heart of defence United’s foundations are much stronger. There are games when it is necessary to reign in your attacking instinct, to wait, weather the storm and be patient in finding and executing the vital knock out blow. It can be a worrying thing to watch – after all, we are more accustom to watching United dominating possession and attacking at a high tempo. However, this performance showed maturity and great belief. Something that should – barring a poor performance at Old Trafford in two weeks time – see United progress into the quarterfinals.

Player ratings: Van der Saar 8, Neville 6, Ferdinand 7, Vidic 8, Evra 6, Giggs 8, Scholes 7, Carrick 7, Ronaldo 6, Rooney 7, Larsson 7.

Manchester United v Charlton - A preview

I expect United to push Charlton further towards relegation. Charlton are 19th in the league with a goal difference of –25. They have lost their last 4 away games. And without Darren Bent, their best marksman in the league is Hasselbaink with a paltry 2 goals. Yes, that is 2 goals. To put that into perspective that is one less than United’s defender Vidic and exactly the same as Darren Fletcher.

So why are Charlton suffering so badly this season? Well when I look down Charlton’s squad I go someway before seeing anything resembling quality. Young, Holland, Ambrose, Thomas, Kishishev, Lisbie, M Bent, Sorondo, Hughes. Yep still waiting. Charlton has some good players but not many very good players that can make a difference. In fact, Scott Carson and Darren Bent are arguably the only two to have made a positive impact. The rest are steady and steady players all to often find themselves in the Championship. And if I was to be truly cutting, I could say that with Alan Pardew at the helm they have the perfect manager to get them there.

Charlton will try their best to frustrate United but I expect the gulf in class to finally tell. Fergie may, with a question mark over Ronaldo and Carrick, turn to Park and Fletcher. But don’t count on it. If Ronaldo and Carrick can play, they will. There was mention that Rooney is suspended after picking up 5 yellows, but this has not been confirmed.

I expect Kuszczak to record his first clean sheet at Old Trafford. Something the guy needs given all the positive talk about Ben Foster at the moment.

Probable team: Kuszczak; Neville, Ferdinand, Vidic, Evra; Ronaldo, Scholes, Carrick, Giggs; Rooney; Larsson

Prediction: 3-0

Player to watch: Scholes, having just scored I expect him to raid forward to good effect

Spurs 0 v Man United 4 - A review

Manchester United rolled over a Spurs team that now has much to reflect on. There was even time for some fun to be had. After a nasty knock to Van der Saar, John O’Shea went in goal much to the amusement of everyone not supporting Spurs. Thankfully, United were already four nil up when Rio Ferdinand decided to play one of his pranks by under-hitting a back pass into the path of Robbie Keane. To everyone’s amusement – including Fergie – John O’Shea tackled his international teammate to a chorus of cheers.

This was Manchester United’s day. Much had been made of this fixture as a potential banana skin. To be fair, until United got the breakthrough it was actually relatively close. As predicted, Spurs lacked fight but had enough quality upfront to pose a threat with Berbatov once again impressive. Lennon was strangely out of sorts - perhaps sensing for once his pace would not be enough when confronted by Evra. Both Giggs and Ronaldo have been schooled by Fergie and as a result were tireless in tracking back, something Malbranque and Lennon did not do, which left Huddlestone and Zakora more exposed. And as predicted this combination were no match for the guile and experience of Scholes and Carrick and were left further confused by Rooney dropping back to receive the ball.

Gardener was continuously turned inside out by the movement of Larsson. His defensive frailties were further exposed when Larsson once again got ahead of him to receive the ball. Gardener decided to lunge across him in a desperate attempt to get the ball. It was a clear penalty but was amazingly waved away by the referee. United players rightly protested at the absurdity of the decision. Something that should not be encouraged but something that surely played a part in the referee’s next decision. Ronaldo received the ball on the outside of the area. He burst past Lee Young Pyo at pace and went down under the challenge of Malbranque, who clearly left a foot in on the winger. Lets face it, when it happened everyone saw it as a penalty. The referee, like us, saw the leg go in and saw Ronaldo go down. He blew his whistle. It was not until half-time when the Spurs technicians decided to replay the incident from every conceivable angle on the big screens in the ground that talk of a dive was encouraged. The truth is we don’t know. If it was a dive, it was art compared to the work of Zakora a few months ago. What is clear is that the referee felt there was contact or intention of contact that resulted in Ronaldo going over.

Despite continuing protestations from the Spurs support, the game was shortly over. The Spurs fans were still booing Ronaldo when they conceded again. Robinson’s goal was attacked incessantly from the start of the second half. Spurs were helpless. Carrick supplied a precise corner onto the head of Vidic and the ball whistled past Robinson.

Spurs had moments. One provided by our own Gary Neville, who decided it would be okay to manhandle Chimbonda inside the penalty area in clear view of everyone. The amusing thing was it was okay, as the referee once again went against all common sense by waving play on. You win some; you Spurs some.

The game got more painful for the home fans when Cristiano produced one step-over at speed to once again outwit Lee Young Pyo and get to the by-line where he sent in a wicked low cross that Robinson failed miserably to deal with and Scholes had time to control the ball between his legs on the ground and slot it home and smile. This really was shaping up to be one of those days for United. The cherry was firmly put on the cake came when Saha – on for Rooney – picked up the ball and under a challenge, span his marker and ran at the Spurs defence. Looking up he provided a perfectly weighted pass to the feet of the unrushing Giggs, who subsequently lifted his shot over Robinson for United’s fourth.

The major difference between Spurs and United was fight, belief and ability. If the only fight Spurs possess is Zakora then they really have problems. A poor man’s Makelele is no answer at this level. Huddlestone was more boulder than builder, when it came to influencing the game. Gardener is so inept he rivals Titus Bramble as the countries worst central defender. And the belief of Paul Robinson had been cut to size by the young guns of Arsenal and has now been truly shredded by the visit of Manchester United.

Player ratings: Van der Saar 8; Neville 7; Ferdinand 7; Vidic 8, Evra 6; Ronaldo 7; Scholes 7; Carrick 7; Giggs 7; Rooney 7; Larsson 7

Man of the match: Vidic

Spurs v Manchester United - A preview

Sunday sees Michael Carrick return to White Hart Lane for the first time since his transfer. I suspect this will concern the Spurs fans more than the player. After all, he has more than enough ability to cope with the challenge of Zakora and Huddlestone. He also will have the luxury of playing alongside a certain Paul Scholes. And although Rooney and Ronaldo will no doubt catch the eye again, it is the combination of Carrick and Scholes that holds the key to ensuring United leave with all three points.

I think too many of the current Spurs team lack fight, which is why they have had problems on the road this season. If you want it summed up, look at Steed Malbranque - good going forward but provides no muscle to an already light- weight Spurs midfield. Zakora is the poor man’s Makelele. However, Spurs do have a decent forward line, something they always seem to focus on. Perhaps to mask the overall failings in the rest of the side. It wasn’t that long ago that I used to hear Spurs fans bragging about having Jurgen Klinsmann, David Ginola and Paul Gascoigne. Ever hear them mention that the same side also had Chris Perry, Dean Marney and Goran Bunjevcevic?

And they are still doing it. Berbatov looks a great buy and Keane, Defoe and Mido all have to be watched as they can all score goals. They also, in Lennon, possess one of the most exciting players playing on the wing in the Premiership. But behind that one is left to wonder how good are Dawson, Gardener, Assou-Ekotto, Zakora, and Rocha?

In fact, I am really looking forward to seeing Lennon run at Evra. But, I cannot wait to see Ronaldo vs Assou-Ekotto, Rooney vs Gardener and Larsson vs Dawson, as Spurs always look capable of conceding - particularly without King in the side. And Spurs may have England’s number one goalkeeper. But I would be prepared to wager that most strikers in the Premiership would say that felt more likely than not to score when one on one against him. For me, he lacks presence, which is perhaps why none of the bigger clubs have come in for him.

On paper, this is one of United’s three tricky away games, with the other two being trips to Liverpool and Chelsea. It is true enough to say that Spurs are usually stronger at home than they are away. However, it is also true that United have won at White Hart Lane on their last 5 visits.

Probable Team: Van der Saar, Neville, Ferdinand, Vidic, Evra, Ronaldo, Scholes, Carrick, Giggs, Rooney, Larsson.

Prediction: 0-2

Player to watch – Carrick